in Search
Welcome to Neopoleon - Sign in | Join | Help
Navigation: Home | Forums | Galleries

Apple - MacBook Pro - Windows - Nerdly Issues

When I went AWOL from work while losing my mind, I knew I had to make a few changes. One of those changes was to de-crazy myself (failed), and the other was to try and separate my personal life from my work life.

Working at Microsoft is a big thing. You're never quite sure what your job is or when you're supposed to do it. You might get hired to code your little fingers off, but then find yourself in the middle of a marketing effort that has you working until midnight for a couple weeks.

You just. Don't. Know.

That can be fun and exciting and neat-o, but it can become overwhelming. You eventually tire of thinking through work related problems while you shower. You don't want to check your work email at 11:00 PM, but you'll do it anyway.

It's easy to give your life and mind over to the company.

I wanted to get my life and mind back. And that isn't an angry sentiment - I was the one who allowed it to happen. Nobody at Microsoft ever asked more of me than I was willing to give, and had I said "No" more often, I may never have reached a point at which I knew things had gone too far.

Step one was to get away from Windows. I work in Windows. I live in Windows. I have several machines across all of which I have Windows installed. At work and at home, it's Windows.

Windows, Windows, Windows.

At the start of my nervous breakdown (or whatever it was), I switched to my iBook. Living in OS X was a good way to get away from what reminded me of work.

It was fancy, but there were too many things I still needed my Windows machines for, so another solution was needed.

During a conversation with my dad, I mentioned that I was thinking about getting a MacBook Pro. He had just picked one up and loved it. As soon as I told him what the plan was, he offered to buy me one.

That's about as effing cool as it gets.

I told him I'd let him subsidize the purchase, but that I wouldn't accept an entirely paid for MacBook. He agreed, although after the thing was purchased, he still gave me a check for the full amount.

Like I said, about as effing cool as it gets.

It's one of the fifteen inch models. An assload of memory, big hard drive, blah blah blah.

And Parallels.

As nice as the thing is, I still couldn't have used it as a full replacement for everything else since there were still those few Windows apps left that I needed.

If you haven't seen Parallels, and you're a nerd, and if you're a nerd who wants to use a Mac but still needs a Windows machine, then I pity your ignorant soul.

When I first heard about Parallels, I thought it sounded like yet-another-virtual-machine-app. And it is, but it goes a few steps further than anything else I've used. To the point that it's one of the single most impressive pieces of software I've ever seen.

For the technically-challenged (who probably aren't even reading this), the simple explanation for what Parallels does is "It's this software thing that let's you run Windows as an application on your Mac."

Not exactly true, but in appearances, this definition should be good enough.

When I started it up, I expected sluggish, crappy performance. That's what VMs are for. My opinion might be tainted by having had to do a lot of the kind of work where you keep three VMs open at once, but there you go - tainted opinion.

What I got instead from Parallels wasn't only all the speed I'd want, but a mode that allows me to run Windows apps without seeing Windows. That is, as though they were Mac apps. Just as I can mouse over the dock and start a native OS X app, I can click on Windows Live Writer - in the dock - and it'll pop up as an app without the rest of Windows.

It's so outer-space neat. Fetch me my robot-suit, Jeeves. Entering hyperspace now, captain. Set your flazer to Incapacitate. Plot a course to Tarragon V, and somebody prep my shuttle.

OUTER.

SPACE.

NEAT.

You can also configure "default" applications. For example, if I'm running a Windows app and I click on a URL in a document, the default app is going to be IE, and this goes for Parallels, too. Under Parallels, though, I can configure it so that Safari (my preferred browser) opens the links - the links I'm clicking inside the Windows VM.

It's been a long time since I've wanted to rub an app in someone's face and say, "LOOK, YOU - LOOK - THIS IS HOW IT'S DONE, DAMN IT. YOU WILL RESPECT THIS SOFTWARE. YOU WILL BECOME YOURSELF PROSTRATE BEFORE IT. AND, NO, I DON'T MEAN 'PROSTATE' - I MEAN 'PROSTRATE.' IF YOU WANT TO BECOME PROSTATE BEFORE IT, THEN THAT'S YOUR OWN BUSINESS."

Speaking of how it's done, I've been back at work a little over a week, and I've gone back to spending my days in Windows and my evenings in OS X. The change from OS X all day to dividing the day between Window and OS X has been shocking. There are things I've tolerated in Windows for a long time - things that genuinely didn't bother me before. Or, perhaps, things I had been exposed to so often that I no longer registered it when one came along.

I have a list. And it's not so much a list of what I find wrong with Windows as much as it is a list of what I find right about OS X. It won't be phrased as such, but that's the general spirit of it.

These are things which, if the Windows team were to implement them, would make Windows far better than it is today.

1. Stop stealing focus

When I'm going about my merry little way in OS X, if there's an app in the background that needs my attention, it'll make itself known, but it won't hijack my whole experience.

In Windows, it doesn't matter what I'm doing - I could be focused on writing (as I am now), and some other app will happily come along, z-order its way on top of everything else, and refuse to piss off until I've clicked on something I don't even care about. I've been dealing with that this week, and it drives me nuts. It doesn't ask you to pay attention - it pushes everything else out of the way and forces you to get involved.

Not cool.

2. Stop with those irritating little bubble messages

After my machine starts up, I just want a clean space to work. What I have instead is a host of little bubble messages in the lower right-hand corner, telling me things like "Your security is stupid" or "Please click on this message to get rid of this message."

I.

Don't.

Care.

If my security is stupid, it's because I set it that way. I don't think nagging a user to change a setting that was intentionally set is a good way to make things safe.

3. Stopping hardware

When I have an external hard drive hooked up to the Mac, I just drag the drive's icon to an eject button on the dock to sever the connection between the laptop and the drive.

In Windows, I have to right-click on this obscure icon that most people will never even know about, click on something ("Stop hardware"? I forget the wording), and then select from a list the bit of hardware I want to stop. Problem is, there's nothing intelligible in the bloody list. There might be five things, all of which look as likely as the others.

I've been doing this for years, and it's still confusing.

What's the big deal? Drag. Drop. Done.

On the Mac, this is a one-click affair. Under Windows, it's at least four clicks. And they're confusing clicks at that.

4. Never, ever, EVER reboot my machine without asking

This one really gets me.

Non-existent on my Mac, but my Windows machine happily reboots itself whenever the fancy strikes.

I was writing a forum post for Channel 9 a couple days ago, and it got up there in length. Not so many words that I sobbed over the loss, but enough work lost and enough frustration gained that I called it a day and went home.

To my Mac.

There's no excuse for it. Yeah, security, whatever.

Bad.

5. Stop asking me to reboot - I'll reboot when I'm good and ready

Another rebooting problem. My machine grabs some updates, installs the updates, and wants me to restart my machine so they'll take effect. I'm fine with that, but I want to reboot on my own time. I hate having a whiny dialogue pop up every few minutes to remind me to reboot.

I KNOW. I KNOW IT'S TIME TO REBOOT. I KNOOOOOOOOW! NOW LET ME WORK.

When I write, interruptions are a Very Bad Thing. I get into a flow of thought that can disappear if I so much as walk three feet for a glass of water. Having that stupid "Reboot now? Well, how about now? Or now?" window appearing every few minutes is enough to make me scream.

That's all.

Five simple things which, if changed, would make Windows a much nicer environment in which to spend significant amounts of time. Windows is spiffy, but the things that work are the things I won't remark. When something happens with so little fanfare that I'm not really aware that it's happened, then it's probably a good thing. Unfortunately, when my attention is repeatedly - and we're talking about over and over every day - drawn away from my work, then all I'm going to remember is the irritating behavior. The good stuff doesn't even get a chance.

For now, at home, I just run XP on my Mac with most of the automatic features turned off.

And I like it that way.

Published Friday, August 24, 2007 3:26 PM by Rory

Filed Under: ,

Comments

 

Daniel Egan said:

How does VS, MSSQL, ETC... work?  Sluggish??  

If not, I might just use my Mac for something other then checking how my sites render...

Thanks Man.

D
August 24, 2007 5:37 PM
 

Tim said:

I am also a long-time Windows user, and also just got a MacBook (partly because I know it will run Windows, partly because I know it'll be the first laptop that *actually* works*).

Re: #2 - The bubble message thing also drives me nuts.  Even after a clean install of XP, it's still drivelling on about nothing all the time.  I was quite surprised after booting OS X the first time...I was waiting for it to say something.  Perhaps offer me some dumbass tour of OS X?

No, it just did nothing.  It took me a while to work out that OS X was just ready for me to do what I wanted to, without wagging its finger at me 8 times before I was allowed to open Word (for example).

Re: #3 - this is actually quite simple - just left-click on the icon instead of right-click.  You get a list of devices - click the one you want to remove.  The list contents are not always intelligible though, as you say.

Windows does a nice thing here where for USB flash drives etc, it will assume you're going to yank it out at any moment, so it flushes writes immediately.  So pretty much after a copy, if you wait 3 seconds you can yank that USB flash drive and Windows won't care (it won't even bug you about it).  You can enable this for individual drives - choose Properties on the drive, go to the 'Hardware' tab, click Properties (again), and go to the 'Policies' tab.  Voila! (Aside: how easy was that?! :-)).

It would be nice if OS X offered this (maybe it does and I haven't found it).

As for #4 and #5 - agree in spades.  Whoever is in charge of the Security policy at Microsoft is a fecking eejit.  Yes, reboot my machine and DESTROY any unsaved data in the process, because there's an important security update!  Now, remind me...security updates...isn't the point of them to help PREVENT me losing data from malicious attacks? No need to worry now - Microsoft cut out the middle-man, and Windows now automatically trashes your data for you.  Excellent.  We're really cooking with gas now.  Let's also not mention the fact that Microsoft mark the WGA as a *critical* update.  I really want to punch the person that decided that, for so many reasons (crying wolf being one of them).

I also like the way when I wake up my Mac, it searches for and reconnects to wifi, and a small status icon in the top right changes.  Windows XP, as well as taking 5 times longer to lock onto wifi after being woken, also feels the need to tell me via a pop-up bubble that it's reconnected - *every* time.  What does it want, a fecking medal?

I have noticed a marked tendency for Windows XP to tell you about things that you *expected* to happen anyway.  If something happens on OS X (like you reconnected to wifi on wakeup), it just assumes you expected that, as it happened the other 800 times in this scenario, so probably best not to tell you about it.

It's a bit like a programmer who has discovered exception handling, and suddenly starts using it for everything, rather than for handling *exceptional* cases.

* My Rule of Laptops: at least one thing/feature/device on your new laptop won't work properly (wifi, media buttons, sleep/resume, etc) - deal with it.  This has applied to just about every laptop I have encountered - I'm happy to say, it doesn't apply to my MacBook.
August 24, 2007 5:44 PM
 

markp said:

I agree with your list, but it won't be long before you have an OSX list of dumb things too, and I'll bet it will look something like mine:
http://intepid.com/2007-04-10/19.05/

PS I tried earlier version of Parallels but ended up switching to VMWare Fusion because it seemed to hog fewer resources (and give me longer battery life). What is called "Coherence" in Parallels is referred to as "Unity" by VMWare... it seems they are very similar in features.
August 24, 2007 6:00 PM
 

markp said:

Oh yes, my favorite Windows feature is when you connect an external USB drive and suddenly XP is thrashing the shit out of it while announcing that it's searching for any old crap on that drive you just plugged in, in case you want to access it RIGHT NOW and see PHOTOS or play MOVIES instead of just browsing to it when you're good and ready.
August 24, 2007 6:34 PM
 

Rory said:

Daniel -

So far, nothing's sluggish. There's even a nifty feature that allows for some DirectX. My favorite mahjongg (or howeverthefuck it's spelled) game is Windows-only, and it requires some OpenGL ballyhoo. It works just fine.

If it can do that, then I doubt it'd have trouble with much else.

I can't say for sure, though, as I haven't tried to run VS inside it yet. I might just do that tonight for kicks. Dunno.

Overall, the performance is far better than I expected.
August 24, 2007 6:59 PM
 

Rory said:

Tim -

I'm in awe. Seriously, seriously in awe.

Laughed all the way through your comment, and then laughed all the way through your site.

It's been a long time since I was last disabled with laughter at finding something somebody *else* wrote to be funny.

Thank you.
August 24, 2007 7:05 PM
 

Rory said:

markp -

"PS I tried earlier version of Parallels but ended up switching to VMWare Fusion because it seemed to hog fewer resources (and give me longer battery life). What is called "Coherence" in Parallels is referred to as "Unity" by VMWare... it seems they are very similar in features."

I didn't even know VMWare had an OS X product. I'll look into it.

Good that they have Unity - Coherence blows me away. I realize that, conceptually, it wouldn't be that hard to implement, but it means they're recognizing there's a market in VMs for consumers (rather than devs, etc.).

"h yes, my favorite Windows feature is when you connect an external USB drive and suddenly XP is thrashing the shit out of it while announcing that it's searching for any old crap on that drive you just plugged in, in case you want to access it RIGHT NOW and see PHOTOS or play MOVIES instead of just browsing to it when you're good and ready."

As with Tim's comment, this one had me laughing. I've done it so many times that I don't even register anymore when Windows does the searchy thing.

Interestingly, after years of encountering that feature, I've never, ever used it.

I do typically want a DVD (movie) to play when I slap it in the drive thing, but I don't want my USB memory device doo-dad to be scanned for a photo that, as you say, I might like to access RIGHT NOW.

Even typing RIGHT NOW in caps makes me laugh.

You captured perfectly the pointlessness of the feature. It reminds me of how I was when I was in withdrawals and just got my hands on some morphine. The crazy look in the eye, the sweat, the shaking... except that I picture someone in the same state trying as quickly and frantically to view pictures of their dog.

Good stuff.
August 24, 2007 7:13 PM
 

PatrickQG said:

I tried VMware all the way through the beta period, but long before it was released had work buy Parallels. Better to use an officially supported product for work, no? (I mostly use Parallels to run Vista + Office 2007. Yes, I'm nuts. Why do you ask?)

VMware lacks the magic-cross-OS-associations feature which totally kicks arse in Parallels, and the most recent (beta? release?) has the same "each windows app is its own OS X window with drop shadow and presence in exposé" stuff, so really Parallels just needs to match the marginally better performance of VMware.

Windows... as Tim says "I have noticed a marked tendency for Windows XP to tell you about things that you *expected* to happen anyway", that's totally it. Mac OS X tells you things when it needs to (like "Your clock is totally set in the past dude. Like years before the machine was made. This might cause some applications to freak out. Like a bad trip freak out. You probably don't want that. Unless you do."), but not that kind of "everything is alright" bubble.

Those bubbles? The feature of Windows that deserves to die a painful horrible death involving swarms of angry badgers. Single worst design idea in the history of this post.
August 25, 2007 1:29 AM
 

Tim said:

"It's been a long time since I was last disabled with laughter at finding something somebody *else* wrote to be funny."

Yay me!  It was probably time to return the favour after your "Excel as a database" cartoon, which is one of my all time favourite things on the interweb (and still sadly seem to need to send it to people with worrying frequency to explain why what they're doing is stupid and wrong).

"except that I picture someone in the same state trying as quickly and frantically to view pictures of their dog."

Now that was funny :-)  

User: "I'm jonesing for some Rover...real baaaad...fix me up, man!"
XP: "Would you like to view some photos? The first one is free."
August 25, 2007 11:51 AM
 

Rory said:

PatrickQG -

"VMware lacks the magic-cross-OS-associations feature which totally kicks arse in Parallels, and the most recent (beta? release?) has the same "each windows app is its own OS X window with drop shadow and presence in exposé" stuff, so really Parallels just needs to match the marginally better performance of VMware."

Does this include the super-dooper integrated clipboard magic?

When I used to demo with VirtualPC, I'd go nuts at the inability to drag and drop files or share the clipboard.

It's so easy with Parallels that I take it for granted. There *is* the character limit for the clipboard, but it's better than nothing, and if I have something to big to clipboard over, I can just drag 'n drop a file instead.

So neat-o.
August 25, 2007 1:38 PM
 

Rory said:

Tim -

"Now that was funny :-)"

Oh... Oh, OH ***OH***.

Oh, don't you dare.

Don't you DARE compliment me back like that. We both know damn well that your comment was scary-funny, and that mine were mere shadows of your funniness.

I OWN this site, you bastard. OWN. Do you know what that means? OWN? It's like "borrow" except that you don't give it back, which for me is the same thing, actually.

My humor was a little tiny moon which, through some freak astronomical accident, was eclipsed by your MIGHTY SUN OF FUNNIER-THAN-ME.

So, Tim... DON'T try to make me feel better about having lost the Funny Beauty Contest here in the comments.

I suggest you start being a little more mature, collect your winnings, and enjoy them.

GOD.
August 25, 2007 1:44 PM
 

PatrickQG said:

I love the ability to drag & drop files from OS X to Parallels. I mean, not that I do it very often (usually after having downloaded something stupid like a VPN installer I created elsewhere to install and test). Copy & Paste though... I use that almost all the time.

One of those things I just take for granted.

Parallels does a wonderful job of making Windows feel like Classic.
August 25, 2007 3:49 PM
 

Grant said:

At risk of being a geek:

1. Stop stealing focus

Download TweakUI, General > Focus, check Prevent applications from stealing focus

Perhaps this should be the default setting, but I know plenty of "typical Windows users" who would miss a flashing taskbar icon and possibly miss some important message or UI interaction because a window that needed focus never got attention.

2. Stop with those irritating little bubble messages

Some are useful to me, some are not. Unfortunately once the feature is available, everyone feels the need to pop everything up as toast. This "overuse of every new feature" really frightens me when I think of what fugly UIs people will build with WPF.

3. Stopping hardware

I right-click the USB drive letter in My Computer and pick "Eject". Does your external HD offer something similar? It seems akin to the description you give of dragging it on the Mac. That will save you from having to use the "Safely Remove Hardware" thing.

4. Never, ever, EVER reboot my machine without asking

I've never experienced this. I'm guessing that it might be because Control Panel > System > Advanced > Startup and Recovery Settings... > Automatically restart is checked by default, and your system is bluescreening and automatically rebooting. Of course, unchecking this setting won't solve the problem, it'll just halt the machine at a bluescreen instead of rebooting it.

5. Stop asking me to reboot - I'll reboot when I'm good and ready

This I can agree with. There really really should be a "stop asking" option on the Windows Update dialog.

In this case, I can see the "logic" (not that I agree with it). Applying updates and _not_ restarting doesn't protect you any more than not applying the updates. So I would suppose the logic is that once the updates have been applied, the system should be restarted for the updates to take effect.
August 25, 2007 3:58 PM
 

Tom said:

I'm gobsmacked this revelation hasn't been ... reveled in (?) before! Have you not wondered why people like Mac better? As someone who basically suckled at a Mac 128k (oh precious beige mother), the beautiful simplicity and non-assumption-that-I'm-stupid'ness of Mac OS is so for granted that reading about your discovery makes me want to cry "yes, Yes! Oh brother, welcome to the fold! We have wept for you long these many years"..

I push my USB stick into many PC boxes every day (promiscuous technoslut that I am) , and I'm still unsure of which 'hardware mass storage device to remove', or whatever the incomprensible gabble is.

I write this on my MacBook, purring with the smug self satisfaction that I love. : ) (That's the computer purring, not me.)
August 25, 2007 4:43 PM
 

Rory said:

Grant -

All the solutions you mentioned are totally valid, but the problem isn't that there aren't solutions - it's that you have to either go and find a solution out there, or you have to know about some obscure system setting.

I used to use the various incarnations of Tweak, but stopped because, although annoyances were suppressed, so was information that I actually *did* need.

Like toast. I could shut it off, but only the visual element was gone. While computering my way around, I'd hear the repeated tones of toast coming and going. I felt like I was in line outside, but not being let into the club.

The focus-stealing solution *is* rather bad, I gotta say. I assume that an app stealing focus has something important to tell me. If I do away with focus theft, then how will I know when one of those messages is being dispatched?

It's not a problem that can be solved simply by doing away with the behavior. The *reason* that behavior exists is important - there are things we need to know. The problem is the implementation. It isn't enough to stop focus theft. The whole thing needs to be redesigned from the ground up.

But, my Mac... I already have all the goodness I've mentioned, but it's just there. No downloads; no funny tweaks.

That's how it ought to be.
August 25, 2007 6:24 PM
 

Rory said:

Tom -

"I'm gobsmacked this revelation hasn't been ... reveled in (?) before! Have you not wondered why people like Mac better?"

I've been using Macs for years, but never as my main machines - replacements for my Windows boxes.

It was during the time off I took following my big crazy that I decided to use a Mac for everything I possibly could.

And it wasn't even using the Mac all the time that made a difference - it was *not* using Windows.

When I finally went back to work and opened a neglected Windows laptop, I was reintroduced to all the nagging and toasting and focus stealing that I had been living without for the previous six or seven weeks. It was like being irritated again for the first time.

My Mac suddenly started looking like safe haven - a way to continue doing my thing without an OS badgering me about things far less important than *anything* I might be doing. I don't care if I'm just playing Minesweeper - back off, yo.

All the naggly bits make sense for an OS from the 90s, but people do a hell of a lot more with their computers now than they did back then. Photos, video, maintaining shitty blogs, games, virtual machines for the masses, and so on. Way back when, when it was only the occasional window that stole focus, and when I was probably only using one app at a time, it wasn't such a big deal.

Now it's intolerable.

Also, my MacBook rocks. Forgetting about all the other crap, I just like this thing.

A lot :)
August 25, 2007 6:31 PM
 

SteveJ said:

Grant -

You've never experienced the auto reboot thing?  Well pull up a chair.  You see, automatic updates (that wonderful windows service that keeps me safe from myself) sometimes decides that an update is SOOOOO important that your computer must be rebooted (this may only count on "unattended" machines, I'm not really sure).  So there's no reboot (remember when windows 2000 came out and you could install one or two things and you didn't have to reboot?  Glorious day!), nag the shit out of you until you reboot, and damn the torpedoes, it's time to reboot.

So the easy solution is to turn off automatic updates.  I'll just go to Windows Update myself, right?  I'm smart enough to handle that.  Oh, but windows update turns automatic updates back on for you if you're stupid enough to try and do the right thing.  Thanks buddy!

So ok, turn it off and remember to turn it off after an update.  Check and check.  Then one day the network admins decided that they would push one of those critical updates to my test server.  The one that had been running a VERY expensive test for days.  Needless to say, after the company flushed those thousands of dollars down the drain (caused by that MUST REBOOT NOW), I now have sole admin access to every computer I touch, viruses, trojans and hackers be damned.  And don't forget your group policy settings (seriously it's this friggin important that I have to have a MSCE to avoid restarts?)

Deep breaths.

I actually don't mind the install updates when you shutdown.  Most people that need security updates (no hardware firewall, no backups, etc)  shutdown their systems daily, if not more often.  Heck boot times are getting back down into the < 2 minute range.  It's not a perfect solution, but it sounds like an option you should be able to pick.
August 25, 2007 6:37 PM
 

gemils said:

#4 and #5 - Go Start > Run and give gpedit.msc a try.  It will fire up your Group Policy editor.  Find your way through Local Computer Policy > Computer Configuration > Administrative Templates > Windows Components > Windows Update.

#4 should be killed by enabling 'No auto-restart for scheduled Automatic Updates installations' and #5 should be taken care of by tweaking 'Re-prompt for restart with scheduled installations' to something that you like.  Mine is at 240 minutes, so that the nag will show up at least once before I leave for the day, and, if I don't shut down the computer, at least once before I come back to work in the morning.
August 25, 2007 8:16 PM
 

Tim said:

gemils:

"#4 should be killed by enabling 'No auto-restart for scheduled Automatic Updates installations'"

Yeah, you'd think, but I'm sure (and I've heard many other people repeat this anecdote) that Windows will sometimes decide to turn that back on for you.  I've never worked out when/why it does it, but as I always install XP with 'Download updates, but don't install', I know that some of my machines have magically been reset to 'Download updates, install, and reboot like you don't care'.

It's very annoying.  I usually know this because I lost some data that was sitting open in a document somewhere and the next morning I'm looking at a login screen.

As far as I'm concerned, whoever is in charge of these policies is on a par with the guy who designed the molex power connector for hard drives.  i.e. if we meet, one of us will die.

August 26, 2007 3:13 AM
 

paul said:

I suspect you have Vista shoes and Apple coordinated outfits that help with the transition from Windows to OSX and the end of each working day....
August 26, 2007 3:38 AM
 

Chris Wisehart said:

Glad to see you getting back on your feet.  I hate Windows but won't go to Apple cause I have just too much learning invested in the other guys.  I do wish they'd stop piling apps up like crazy and integrate some of them into one.  How lame is having to use .pdf, .xls, .ppt, .dox, .ppt, +, +, + document apps and formats.  I know you could build and app that intgrates all into one but won't cause why sell one when you can sell 10?
August 26, 2007 3:07 PM
 

markp said:

FYI I just migrated my VMWare XP install to the latest Parallels (very cool that this is possible) and can confirm that Parallels still uses way more resources. Having XP "idling" in VMWare costs ~5% CPU, whereas Parallels eats ~17%.

Feature set in Parallels is a bit nicer with the smart associations trick, but it's not enough to make me switch back (VMWare are bound to copy those features anyway :)
August 26, 2007 9:31 PM
 

Rory said:

paul -

"I suspect you have Vista shoes and Apple coordinated outfits that help with the transition from Windows to OSX and the end of each working day...."

Yes :)

The shoes report on my progress throughout the day:

"You just stepped. You just stepped. You just stepped. You just ste..."

Sometimes they start dancing - with my feet still in them. They don't ask - and it gets me a lot of unwanted attention. The only way they stop is if I give in and say, "You guys did a really good job."

They periodically unlace themselves - totally spontaneous. I never know when it's going to happen. Sometimes I'm right in the middle of a conversation, and my entire train of thought is lost when I have to pause to tie them again.

As for the Apple clothing - it just hangs there like one of those fancy Apple Store bags. It doesn't ask anything of me, and when I try to move an arm or a leg, my volition is obeyed without question.

The occasional speck of dirt finds its way onto the outfit, but the clothing doesn't insist that it be cleaned - it waits patiently for *me* to decide when the cleaning will take place.

Yep. That's my life right now...
August 26, 2007 10:54 PM
 

Rory said:

markp -

"FYI I just migrated my VMWare XP install to the latest Parallels (very cool that this is possible) and can confirm that Parallels still uses way more resources. Having XP "idling" in VMWare costs ~5% CPU, whereas Parallels eats ~17%."

Huh. Interesting.

Have you checked to see what setting you're using for CPU consumption in Parallels? It's dumbed-down, but you can tell it to either favor the host OS or the guest.

I don't know what it's using on my system, but XP is running in the background the entire time I'm using the Mac. I haven't experienced any performance problems yet, and that includes having Photoshop open in XP with Apple DVD Player running, a bajillion Safari windows, Mail, Page (from iWork), and other stuff.

It may be that it uses more CPU when idle, but it has yet to affect my experience.

That said, I'm curious about VMWare now. I used to use it for dev work, and I loved it. If they *do* copy all the nifty Parallels features, then I'm there.

Another cool thing I found out yesterday... Carl Franklin wants me to record new episodes for the podcast he produces of my stuff (the request isn't new - it's how I'm doing it), and I thought I was going to have to do it with my tablet. That'd be fine, but my tablet *really* needs to go back to XP, as Vista kills it. But, instead of futzing around with that, I installed my recording app on XP under Parallels, and the thing actually works. I can do everything inside OS X.

The only thing I can't do yet is draw my comics, and that's a big thing. I'm thinking about picking up a Wacom digitizer, but I think I might prefer to stick with the tablet. Being able to draw directly on the screen is a very nice convenience.
August 26, 2007 11:01 PM
 

Pixie said:

I have the same setup -- it's almost an orgasmic experience.  I use VMware fusion -- use Vista both with Boot camp and as a VM partition, and it is shockingly perfect.  When I'm not on the road, I have everything set up such that my external monitor sits above my laptop monitor, and I run my Vista VM in the full screen monitor above, and MacOS in the monitor below, with a minimized Ubuntu server running in the background,  and it all just WORKS...  I can move my mouse seamlessly between the two screens, copy and paste, I get full real estate from both machines, and life ROCKS.  It's a full LAMP stack with testing platforms on all of my key operating systems.... RowrrRR!

My only two complaints -- file systems and the boot loader.  The only file system that allows read/write between Windows & Mac is FAT32.  But FAT32 sucks, and has a 2gb filesize limitation that messes me up.    The other issue is having to hold down the #$%ing option key EVERY time I boot, in order to be able to select which OS I want to come up.

These are small complaints though. Mostly I just sit there and work with a big dumb grin on my face....
August 27, 2007 9:07 AM
 

Mat Hall said:

@Pixie:

"The only file system that allows read/write between Windows & Mac is FAT32."
Download Fuse for OS X (binaries here: http://www.ntfs-3g.org/), then you can read/write NTFS to your heart's content.  (Lack of write support natively is down to MSFT's licensing/lack of documentation.)

"The other issue is having to hold down the #$%ing option key EVERY time I boot, in order to be able to select which OS I want to come up."
Eh? You only have to hold it down if you don't want to boot the default OS -- if you *always* boot in to the non-default, change the default!
August 29, 2007 10:20 AM
 

blackfrog said:

Neopoleon - Welcome to Macintosh!

Rest assured that coding for OS X is as rewarding as using OS X.  Give XCode a whirl.  Check out CoreData. Check out Quartz Compositions.  You'll wonder why you were so happy with MFC for all those years.

       (!)


August 29, 2007 10:31 AM
 

Switcher said:

Pixie,  re: your 2nd complaint...

"BootChamp (download) is a small utility I wrote that simplifies booting into Windows on your Intel Mac. Instead of using System Preferences to change your startup disk, or holding down Option to select another volume on startup, BootChamp only asks for your password, and does the rest without user input."

http://www.kainjow.com/downloads/BootChamp.zip
August 29, 2007 10:52 AM
 

Brian said:

@ Pixie:

Try Mike Bombich's BootPicker.

http://www.bombich.com/software/bootpicker.html

Mike is the author of a number of can't-live-without-them utilities, actually.
August 29, 2007 11:18 AM
 

andy said:

if u really hate distractions when working, check out WriteRoom for mac. there is a free version and a pay version ($25), and its a full screen text editor, no buttons, no alerts. its really quite nice, and i use it all the time
August 29, 2007 11:27 AM
 

Patrick said:

One of the features that I appreciate the most in OSX is the ability to do 99% of tasks within a standard user account. It kills me that I need to run as an Administrator in Windows to do routine tasks without having to log out and log back in. And don't even get me started on Vista's UAC - that steaming pile of turd is probably one of the biggest reasons I haven't and probably never will upgrade from XP to Vista. All the eye candy in the world means squat if an OS can't properly handle computer rights in a sane way.
August 29, 2007 12:02 PM
 

Ben said:

Mac OS X applications steal the focus too. Have you not been using a Mac for that long?

(If you know a way to prevent this, let me know)

A couple examples I can think of are when you put in an Audio CD, and iTunes insists of popping to the front (even if it's already running). Or when you plug in a digital camera and iPhoto jumps to the front. There are several other apps/instances when this happens. It annoys the shit out of me because it seems so un-Mac-like.

Yes, some apps will just bounce their icon up and down in the dock. But others steal the focus. It's really annoying when I'm doing something like typing an email, or writing a report, and another app jumps to the front mid-sentence.

I would love to be able to turn this off!!!

Ben
August 29, 2007 12:10 PM
 

Ralph Megna said:

For Ben:  Every single issue you mention of stealing focus (audio CD/iTunes, digital camera/iPhoto, etc.) is very easily remedied.  No extra software needed.  Just set the control panels and application preferences.

Just to be clear, I agree that the default behavior is irritating; but, honestly, it is easily fixed:

Go to System Preferences>CDs & DVDs

Go to Image Capture>Preferences>General
August 29, 2007 12:46 PM
 

Tom said:

@Ben:

For CD's -- go to System Preferences, CDs and DVDs  -- you can elect what to do when an music CD, photo CD, blank CD, or DVD is inserted.

Also, in iTunes -- go to Preferences, Advanced, Importing tab.  You can elect how iTunes handles audio CD's by default.  If you're doing a lot of CD ripping, there's a handy "Import CD and Eject" option.

To fix iPhoto -- it's non-obvious.  Find the Image Capture app in Applications.  You can use the preferences to tell OS X what to do when a camera is attached.



August 29, 2007 1:08 PM
 

Mark said:

Pixie: Give rEFIt a try - it is a boot'loader that gives a rather Mac-like boot menu allowing you to choose which OS to boot into (and is necessary for triple booting, if you're that way inclined ;-)). It appears each time the computer starts, without having to hold down any keys. You can set a time out and default, too. The menu includes bootable CDs and USB pens, showing icons appropriate to the device and OS, and even includes icons for Linux ;-)


I converted to the Mac 4 years ago, and haven't looked back. However, OS X is not without its annoyances. One of my favourites, which has been there all the time that I've been using it, is the issue with file servers: if you mount a network drive (afp:// or smb://) and then that server becomes unavailable (e.g. if you forgot to eject the drive before putting your laptop to sleep, then wake it up in a different location), you get locked out of the entire system GUI for up to 3 minutes! Then it finally shows a dialog box telling you that the mount is unavailable, and asks if you want to disconnect.

Which reminds me, on OS X - when you move the mouse pointer over the left-hand pane in Finder, an eject button appears beside each ejectable volume, which allows true one click ejecting (no dragging required).

I recently got myself a MacBook Pro (my first Intel Mac), and immediately installed Parallels and used Windows for the first time in years. I had forgotten just how frustrating those things are in Windows. It really surprised me.

One final anecdote - I love how those little bubbles and 'restart now, now, or now, or shall I pester you again in two minutes?' like to appear in the middle of people's PowerPoint presentations. It is hilarious. I especially like how some PC manufacturers have been 'inspired' by this, with such things as "Your battery is fully charged" blasting out of the PA system during a presentation.
August 29, 2007 1:19 PM
 

Joe said:

Needing a new laptop for a conference a couple months ago, I gave Apple a shot -- 15" MacBook Pro.  Long story short, my old system is still humming in my ear, but not doing much else.  I'm 100% moved over.

My experience with Parallels and Fusion is the opposite of others here.  Fusion was consuming twice as much CPU doing nothing and its performance was atrocious -- subjectively 2-4X worse, practically unusable.  And yet Parallels only virtualizes one core.  It must be something about my configuration.  A two-toed sloth wouldn't put up with the experience I got out of it.  (And yeah, I tried feeding it different quantities of RAM.)

VS 2005 runs great for me, BTW.  

Still waiting for the happy-dance compulsions to pass...
August 29, 2007 1:22 PM
 

Pedro Vera said:

I switched to OS X over four years ago, but for my current job I was issued a Dell. A year passed and the Dell laptop gave me nothing but grief, and right at the same time I started begging for a Mac Book Pro, we had a new hire that was also a Mac user, so the boss decided he might as well buy two Mac Book Pros in one shot.

So far Parallels 2.x (XP SP2) has worked pretty damn good, and this is while running both SQL Server 2000 and 2005 developer editions, VS 2003 and VS2005, Outlook, Adept SQL Diff, and dozens of browser windows opened. All this while I have a lot of things running on the OS X side (Camino, Xchat Aqua, AdiumX, Textwrangler, VLC). Fantastic.

I upgraded to Parallels 3 but so far except Direct X, and the mapped drive from OS X, I don't see much difference. Parallels is so good that I describe this Mac Book Pro as the best windows laptop I have ever used.
August 29, 2007 1:32 PM
 

Roofus said:

@Ben:

All the examples you state are situations where you are physically interacting with the computer input devices (Disk, Camera).  They don't happen randomly or through external input (ie, some program/website/etc that changes state).

Given that, I can forgive Microsoft and Apple for making the decisions that they did in these cases.  

What is more irritating is the non-expected focus change.  Once this caused me an issue as I was busy typing a password in a webpage and some other app stole the focus, and as my colleague watched, I typed the remainder of the password in plaintext right on the offending app (I had a space in the password, which ate the dialog that popped up).   Have never had that happen on a mac.
August 29, 2007 1:47 PM
 

ChrisP??? » Blog Archive » Microsoft Angestellter ??ber Mac OS X said:

August 29, 2007 2:40 PM
 

Rocco said:

to pixie: there's MacFUSE (it's on google code) that should have a NTFS filesystem in userspace option
August 29, 2007 2:47 PM
 

Rory said:

blackfrog -

"Neopoleon - Welcome to Macintosh!"

Thanks, but I've been here for years :)

I think the only thing that's different is that I now use Macs at home exclusively. It's quite nice.

"Rest assured that coding for OS X is as rewarding as using OS X.  Give XCode a whirl.  Check out CoreData. Check out Quartz Compositions.  You'll wonder why you were so happy with MFC for all those years."

Yeah - I've been playing around for a long time. I familiarized myself with Cocoa and Objective-C. I liked it, but I decided I wouldn't come back until garbage collection. I've been spoiled over the years by Java and .NET. I still found Objective-C to be an interesting language, and I was *really* thankful to find it instead of C++.

I recall having read that development stopped on it, but the Java dev experience was amazing. It was the tightest Jave client integration I'd ever seen.

Then there's RealBasic. It's improved over the years, though the version I was using Back When felt really primitive compared to .NET alternatives. Not being insulting here - it really did feel like taking a three year trip back in time. Despite whatever aesthetic issues I may have had with it, it was still the quickest way to create dirty little helper apps (stuff like being able to easily swap out Stickies databases at the touch of a button).

Because I missed bash, I also had fun with Python. I never build anything "real" with Python - I just like the way it feels, so I code for kicks.

I haven't looked at all this stuff in a long time, though. I'll check it out :)
August 29, 2007 2:52 PM
 

Rory said:

Patrick -

"And don't even get me started on Vista's UAC - that steaming pile of turd is probably one of the biggest reasons I haven't and probably never will upgrade from XP to Vista."

I agree, and it's too bad. The sentiment behind it is well-intentioned, and the team that worked on it is full of really kind people, but the implementation drives me insane, so it's the first thing I turn off when I install Vista.
August 29, 2007 2:54 PM
 

Daniel P. Brown said:

Rory,

A guy on MySpace forwarded this article as a bulletin.  As a fellow code geek and a full-time (well, 90%+) Linux user myself, I have to say, I really enjoyed the article.  Not only for its technical aspect, mind you, but for the flow of how it was written.  I thought it was actually a Great[er] Job than Tim & Eric's "Awesome" Show on Adult Swim.

My question, though, is how it handles exceptions.  With Wine, for example, you get a core dump, which actually gives you useful - and sometimes even usable - information on how to recreate and possibly correct (or at least avoid) the problem.

Keep up the good work, and consider me another reader who will be returning to check you out now.

   ~ Dan
August 29, 2007 3:22 PM
 

PapayaSF said:

Every time I plug my thumb drive into the Compaq laptop (XP) that I use to check website code in IE6 (don't get me started on that), I get a little window informing me that it would operate faster if I plugged it into a USB 2 port. But of course, the laptop DOES NOT HAVE a USB 2 port, and I haven't been able figure out how to turn off the message. How can the OS be so dumb as to suggest I use hardware that isn't there?
August 29, 2007 3:45 PM
 

gzavier said:

Guys, well done.
Probably one of the first places where this did not go down the road of a "My OS is better than your OS"-Godwin point asymptotic comment thread. Although now that FSJ put it in the spotlight, might change.
But what I find interesting (and that few Mac bashers really realize) is that most people who praise the Mac do it by comparison. They SWITCHED or at least used both OSes.
And tha is what we see here: not that OS X is sooo perfect, but that it got so many things right, which Wndows manage to get so wrong it looks like it is done on purpose.
Now please don't get me started on the effing Finder AFS mount... (still trying to find some solutions, like an auto-unmont on sleep/ netwrk disconnect)
August 29, 2007 3:53 PM
 

MacPhisto said:

I guess your realy starting to like OSX but you wont admit it!:)

What about a OS that range itself to actually not support a brand new hardware? Wow, i was impressed!
August 29, 2007 4:00 PM
 

Fake Steve brags about MS guy converting to Apple « Leaving my “logs” on the web. said:

August 29, 2007 4:20 PM
 

markp said:

FSJ must be sending a hell of a lot of traffic your way because I'm getting a bunch of people disagreeing with me at my place... and this is not something I am accustomed to!

It seems that even if you preface with "I like OSX better, except..." you will still get zealots telling you to stick with windows
August 29, 2007 5:04 PM
 

Eric said:

I've been thinking and thinking and thinking of getting a iMac, and I think you've pushed me over the edge.  

I think Windows would be greatly improved if it gave you a test when you installed it and if you are a dumb moron you get all the ballons and crap to remind you that you need to wipe your butt or that the sun is hot.  

If you pass the test you get the actual admin mode of Windows where it assumes you know what you're doing and won't question your every move.  Is a registry tweak REALLY neccissary to stop pop-up ballons?

I'm a MCSA and a network admin and think I should be able to swipe my useless MCSA card through my computer to let it know that I sorta know what I'm doing.  I'm ready for something to just work, it's only me being a tightwad that has kept me from the mac cult and also a unwillingness to shave my head.

I won't even go into how HORRIBLE Vista is.  If you notice the comments, almost everyone is still using XP, there's a reason for that.  I'm off to sell children now so I can afford the iMac I want.
August 29, 2007 5:08 PM
 

luis said:

third comment.

You are a microsoftian and don't know that you can disconnect your ext hard drives by LEFT CLICKING the button in the corner, which pops a list of the things you want to disconnect? That's down to 2 clicks friend. But of course, you can't beat drag n drop from OSX. ;) Still, hope that helps.
August 29, 2007 5:13 PM
 

Rip Ragged said:

Good stuff, Rory.

I've been a MS at work, Mac at home guy for 20 years. I laughed my ass off.

You captured my personal experience perfectly. You only missed one thing: the cryptic DOS-looking logon screen that seems quite important to itself, but tells me a bunch of stuff I don't understand, too fast for me to read it.

I'm bookmarking this place. Your writing is fun to read.
August 29, 2007 5:25 PM
 

Jonathan said:

Started on Windows 3.1 and first moved to a Mac running System 7.5, with intermittent use of Windows 95 to NT 4 up until I went Mac only from 9.x all the way up to 10.4.x. However, I started a new job almost 2 years ago with a Windows/PC only policy, and your list is so close to the bone it makes me cry.  What really, truly gets my goat about the pop-up balloons is the one that continually appears to tell me that no wireless networks are available. Why? That'll be due to me physically turning my wireless card off you stupid bloody computer, so of course there are no fricking wireless networks available, and I intentionally have none available so stop bloody telling me that none are available!

I have a no. 6 for the list - the inability to rename files or folders that are "in use" (even when they are not from my perspective as a user - Office 2003 has a terrible habit of not clearing the tmp files it creates after you close the file you were working on which is why I put "in use" in quotes... I know this because I have hidden files showing). I am constantly having to quit Word just to be able to change a folder name so that I can structure the content on my hard drive and it drives me fricking nuts. MacOS - do it on the fly in the Finder and the file name even updates in the application that is "using it" at that time.

...hmmm, sorry for the rant!

I honestly feel as though I am once again living in the stone age of computing.
August 29, 2007 5:30 PM
 

pixie said:

Dear lord,  I can see I need to complain here more often :)  All my wishes are coming true!  Of course, now I'm going to have to come up with new things to be dissatisfied with... I'm sure it won't take long.

I'll definitely look at the boot loader alternatives and Fuse too.  Thanks to everyone who replied.  

Cheers,

Pix
August 29, 2007 5:33 PM
 

E-Bitz - SBS MVP the Official Blog of the SBS "Diva" said:

In a day of ironies... Windows XP sp3 is announced.... Windows Vista SP1 and Windows XP SP3 Announcement
August 29, 2007 5:34 PM
 

Ben said:

I guess I didn't make myself clear earlier. Yes, I know how to change the default behavior when I put in a CD or plug in my digital camera. That's pretty basic stuff.

What I don't like, is how it pops apps to the front. If I'm already running iTunes, but Safari currently has the focus, and I put a CD in the drive --- why should iTunes pop to the front? Maybe I don't want to listen to the CD right then. Maybe I'm putting it in because I want to do something with it other than play it in iTunes. Who knows? Yes, I may want it to show up in the iTunes sidebar when it mounts... but why shouldn't *I* be the one who controls when iTunes is the frontmost app?

It's really annoying.

Ben
August 29, 2007 6:37 PM
 

Viswakarma said:

Well articulated angst that the use of Windows creates in a person!

I can empathize with you fully!

I am an end-user working for a very large Fortune 500 Corporation. For eight hours I suffer through the insanity of Windows, and breathe a sigh of relief when I get home and use the Mac OS X.
August 29, 2007 6:44 PM
 

Randy Hudson said:

"I familiarized myself with Cocoa and Objective-C. I liked it, but I decided I wouldn't come back until garbage collection. ...
"I also had fun with Python. I never build anything "real" with Python - I just like the way it feels, so I code for kicks."

You should look into PyObjC. It's a binding of Python to the various Objective C libraries (including Cocoa). Among other coolnesses, you get garbage collection for free.
August 29, 2007 7:01 PM
 

Eric Seiden said:

What a bloody fantastic post. I have to use it at work and I despise it. Like you I am a Mac person at home. Windows doesn't HAVE to be bad, it just HAPPENS to be bad. Just like OS-X doesn't have to be good, it just IS. It's not the software. It's the vision of the company BEHIND the software. Microsoft has lost its way. Apple hasn't (mostly).

August 29, 2007 7:11 PM
 

Apple iPhone Resources said:

August 29, 2007 7:24 PM
 

Michael Natale said:

Great post.

VMWare's Fusion for OS X works as well as Parallels if you haven't tried it.  Both products have their own little bits of strangeness.  VMWare Fusion has some UI weirdness that happens when you run in UNITY mode - it clutters up the dock if you have lots of apps open.  Parallels Coherence is much nicer.  

August 29, 2007 7:37 PM
 

Cam said:

I think those are some excellent points regarding Windows.  I'm primarily a Mac OS X user and I dread having to log into a Windows box because of all the waiting I have to do.  The system will boot, appear to be loaded, but NO--WAIT for it... I'm hassled by a variety of bubbles and other odds and ends and its really a chore to deal with them.

I don't understand how Windows users put up with them, but it drives me away from Windows screaming.

I wish Apple did do a better job at explaining the OS to "switchers."  It'd be awesome if they had some instructional videos or guides that explain the OS (especially the green "optimize" button).  The quickest way to find a Windows user on a Mac is one who has expanded all of their windows to fill the screen.

I know people that try to use their Mac as if it were Windows and get frustrated by it.  Sure their are some simularities, but there are really different philosophies going on!

Anyways...

August 29, 2007 8:33 PM
 

Marty said:

#3: This is easier on a Mac than anything. ONE CLICK:

Right click (yes, on a Mac) on the drive and select Eject from the menu.

If your on a laptop, hold control (which simulates a right click), and click on the drive, select eject.

Before someone says "that's two clicks, not one". No, it's one. Don't let go of the mouse button. It clicks and selects menu items in the same click.

More: In any sidebar, there is an eject symbol next to every drive. In iTunes, same goes for iPods. In iPhoto, same goes for cameras.

I know some of this is obvious, but it's more for Windows users interested in features of Mac OS X...
August 29, 2007 9:35 PM
 

anon said:

Nice to see that the douchebags responsible for Windows cannot even create a product that they like.  You are not the only one in Windows who prefers OSX.  That also means you have failed at your job.  Where were these complaints at beta1?  Beta2?  RC0?  Jeez if the people responsible for the os can't make it into something they like what's the point?  Do us a favor and get out before you fail on win7 as well.
August 29, 2007 9:52 PM
 

Vicky said:

Its not my problem, that your OS is so bad that you need to update it so very often and the REBOOT!!! what the hell is that anyway??? Its my machine, I want it to work the way I say! And thats all! Im seriously thinking of OS X... not tht Im a Windows fan anyway. The coolest thing they invented is probably IE.
August 29, 2007 11:11 PM
 

Julio Mendoza-Medina said:

Unbelievable!!

We are so much intoxicated with Windows, the first thing we think and want to do after buying a Mac is running Windows in our Mac. That's the biggest PENDEJADA we can think of and do. Me included.

Yes, that's one of the first things I thought, and I also wanted to install Windows on my (only 3 days with it) iMac using BootCamp. But you know what? FORGET ABOUT IT!.

There is no doubt in my mind we can (and will) always find whatever we want (or we need) for our Mac OS X. I don't think there is something Windows can do a Mac cannot do.

Do not get me wrong. I am not saying trash your Windows away. No. I am saying DO NOT INSTALL WINDOWS ON YOUR MAC. WE ALREADY HAVE IT on our other machines and also at work.

Hope this helps clear our minds out and bring us back to sanity!
August 29, 2007 11:43 PM
 

Rory said:

Julio -

"There is no doubt in my mind we can (and will) always find whatever we want (or we need) for our Mac OS X. I don't think there is something Windows can do a Mac cannot do."

Let's take inventory of certain facts:

1. There are at least, like, fifty Windows apps.

2. There are at least, like, fifty OS X apps.

Given all these apps, and given that many of us use both OS's, is it really likely that, among all these, there isn't a single app that doesn't exist for the other OS?

Find me an OS X app that allows me to post to a .Text blog (that *works*). If you can do that, you'll give me one reason less to spend time in Parallels.

And what about apps that *could* be replaced with a Mac equivalent, but only at pointless cost to me? I already have an audio editor that does what I need, and I can't run it on the Mac. I don't use GarageBand because, fancy as it is, it doesn't have all the functionality I need. So, I *could* go out and spend another $500 on a suitable sound editor, but why would I do that when I can just run mine under XP in Parallels?

These are just a couple things to think about. You should also consider that your goals may very well differ from those of others. *I* don't want to ditch Windows. I *like* Windows. I'd just like to see some changes in it. But I don't want to give up the things I like about some Windows apps just because some Windows features bug me. With the Mac and Parallels, I can avoid the frustrations I listed in the post, and I can spend the majority of my time in OS X.

I've seen a lot of this WHY WOULD ANYBODY USE WINDOWS WITH A MAC BLEEEAAGGH! going on, and it's not especially useful.
August 29, 2007 11:54 PM
 

Reihe: das beste Betriebssystem. Teil 2: Windows. said:

August 30, 2007 2:37 AM
 

Ben-o said:

I must say, it's nice to see that there are others that can blissfully co-exist as cross-platformers.  I've also been very impressed with civility and intelligence displayed in the comments here (well, for the most part).  Some times those OS wars can get almost as nasty as those Coke v. Pepsi debates or those Yankees vs. Mets debates.

I also absolutely *love* running Parallels in coherence mode at work.  It confuses the hell oout of people passing by.
August 30, 2007 3:44 AM
 

peterp@n^ said:

5. Stop asking me to reboot - I'll reboot when I'm good and ready

I KNOW. I KNOW IT'S TIME TO REBOOT. I KNOOOOOOOOW! NOW LET ME WORK.

When I write, interruptions are a Very Bad Thing.

yeah man, i agree with that.. and what about while typing and having this pop-up message on top of other windows?? oh, man i'd better kill it, cause it gets on top and on my tempo of writing i accidentaly "hit" this damn letter key that is responsible for reastarting (u know this underlined letter u can press for a command instead of using the mouse)
or enter key to change line so it takes it as i accept rebooting!!..
it really freaks me out!! so wtf?? i get this critical update designed to protect me of loosing data while i lose all my work cause the system wanted to get restarted!!
anyway..
i'd better go to MacOS X

cheers
August 30, 2007 4:16 AM
 

P said:

I completely agree with the above. Windows is annoying in so many ways, and those bubbles - whereever they appear - are just one part of it. Whenever I clean up the start menu (delete all the readmes and links to manufacturers website and garbage), Windows insists that any shortcut I have moved is a new app. It doesn't give up about it either.

To be fair, you can eject stuff by rightclicking them in My Computer, but you still get that stupid confirmation box.
August 30, 2007 7:06 AM
 

Tom Servo said:

Once you've been gone from what has become the Windows experience, you really don't want to get back there.

In the past, I did several excursions into the BSD world. I would have stayed there for the technical merits, but the text mode console nor Gnome 1.4 have cut it for me. At home, you still want some usability. So I went back to Windows for a few more years, accumulating rage over all the bullshit it's giving me, not to mention the ever increasing hand holding and dumbing down of interfaces (not that it's a good thing, but give me a damn expert mode then).

Like 8-9 months ago, I've installed Solaris Express into a VM to toy around with ZFS, of which I've been reading a lot, and as such came in contact with Gnome 2.1x and was pretty surprised by it. I've switched to running it natively and am not missing Windows anymore (after initial but short withdrawal syndroms), except for gaming (WINE sucks).

Focus stealing and the bubbles, on your list, annoyed the living shit out of me. And they don't even intend to fix former. MS' Raymond Chen, supposedly very bright, told me it's virtually impossible without causing a mess. Yay for that. The reboot warnings, never saw them on my machine. Probably related to me using the server versions of Windows, where spontaneous reboots are a no-no. But still bugged the hell out of me when doing things on my mom's laptop.
August 30, 2007 7:06 AM
 

Richard Drysdall said:

 
Grant said:
>At risk of being a geek:

>>1. Stop stealing focus

>Download TweakUI, General > Focus, check Prevent applications from stealing focus

Doesn't work for me - I've had TweakUI installed with this setting on for years, under both Windows 2000 and Windows XP. Applications still manage to steal the focus sometimes.

I hate it when I'm typing and I see a dialog flash up for just a fraction of a second - because the key I pressed happened to click one of the buttons. So I sit there thinking about what applications I'm running, what that dialog might have been, and what key I might have pressed...
August 30, 2007 7:31 AM
 

JCD said:

August 30, 2007 8:41 AM
 

Ron said:

Extremely funny post and follow ups. I'll try to add some things that annoy the hell out of me about Windows:

The Alt-Tab task switcher. What's up with that? Ever have to click through 20 "explorer" icons to get to the specific window you wanted? (Yeah, you can also go to the task bar, but that involves moving hand to the mouse - annoying....) OSX, Cmd-Tab to the application, then Cmd-` to the specific window. Fast, quick, easy. Or, you can even use your mouse to select the app. Or... use expose for finding the window you're looking for. MS only has 2 views into the same pile.

The entire Start button disaster. OSX has the dock, but I almost never use it. I downloaded blacktree.com's QuickSilver and never use the mouse to load an app unless I can't remember what it's called, or it's MySQL (binary starts via a script in a non-standard from OSX's POV location).


And you're missing one of the biggest peeves of mine about windows and laptops: going into stand-by mode. On a brand new Dell 820D at work, here's what you have to do:

Open Network Properties from any of the 5 different non-intuitive ways to get to it, click on your wireless LAN connection and open properties, click the "configure" button on the adapter in the top of the general tab, click on the advance tab, in properties, you'll find something like "Power Save", click on that, and disable it.

Simple, no?

If you don't do this, apparently windows is so brain dead that when the driver manages the power mode of the wireless adapter and it's stopped, it will stop the stand-by mode to wait on a response from the powered down wireless adapter, and won't power up ever. Not only that - you can't bring the machine back reliably from this state, meaning a hard reboot.

The balloons can be forever silenced by a registry hack. Windows Update and a host of other "services" are disabled on initial login always. (This also happens to close a whole series of vulnerabilities). In general I run with between 4 and 9 processes on bootup before installing *my* software. Yes, there's a host of things I don't have: Fast User Switching (who needs it? It's my bloody machine), remote access to the registry (umm, security anyone?) themes (they're mostly useless CPU eating crap anyways) and my personal favorite on hard-wired desktops: Wireless Zero Configuration Service.

August 30, 2007 9:30 AM
 

Rory - Neopoleon said:

I want to be very clear about a few things. For the Neopoleon readers who're WTFing at their monitors...
August 30, 2007 1:22 PM
 

said:

August 30, 2007 5:30 PM
 

RET said:

Ben said: "If I'm already running iTunes, but Safari currently has the focus, and I put a CD in the drive --- why should iTunes pop to the front? Maybe I don't want to listen to the CD right then."

Uhhh, but you've stopped whatever you were working on to find a CD and put it in the drive. That seems like fairly proactive behaviour. It just isn't the same thing as dialogs that appear unbidden while you're actually working (and concentrating) on something else. Calling that "really annoying" seems like a hell of a stretch.

"Maybe I'm putting it in because I want to do something with it other than play it in iTunes."

If you're in the habit of doing that, maybe change those preferences?

cheers
RET
August 31, 2007 8:00 AM
 

Random-sysadmin said:

Well, I find it personally hilarious that a Microsoft employee is stuck in the same boat as many of my users.  A bunch of us in IT discovered a much easier way to eject USB keys... LEFT click the icon in the tray and pick the device you want to eject.  This completely goes against all preconceptions of M$ UI, but it 'Just works.'  (More so, we have a GP set that blocks the 'extra' screen for some reason - we're not even /trying/ to stop it.)

Personally, fixing and maintaining M$ stuff pays the bills, but I have a company MacBook in my briefcase for dev work [I asked nicely], and a Mini at home.  I'm a *nix guy, and love OS X for daily use as it really "Just works."  Still, I have to take issue with your comment about rebooting after updates, as OS X is almost equally poor on this one...it forces you to Reboot, though you can do so at your leisure...and press Cmd-H to hide it...but you cannot quit the update app. :-/  OTOH, you can stop the WUAU service to shut it up...I'm grateful to a friend for pointing that one out to me.

Still, glad to see you've come to see the light. :-)
August 31, 2007 8:18 AM
 

New Customer Feedback Program at Microsoft « Arcane Code said:

August 31, 2007 8:14 PM
 

Vista Nags, Bugs and the Reader???s Experience « The Reader said:

September 1, 2007 9:58 PM
 

Rapping with your Mac « Can’t see nothing but the source code said:

September 2, 2007 6:47 PM
 

Harlemite said:

Just wanted to let you know your article was definitely worth linking to and blogging about. Because of this article, I'll be back.

http://technicalities.blogspot.com/2007/09/thats-what-im-talking-about.html

Harlemite
September 3, 2007 1:07 AM
 

jpb said:

You're forgetting the best part of Parallels/VMWare - you install everything into your windows disk image, then copy it somewhere. Keep all your data out of the windows image (just put apps in it), then when it decides to eat its own entrails, you can just recopy the image from the backup and be working again ten minutes later, with no hassles.
September 3, 2007 3:23 PM
 

Mac or Windows? - Page 7 - Cadillac Owners said:

September 4, 2007 4:43 PM
 

Ben @ Parallels said:

Rory -

Glad you like our stuff.  We here at Parallels lie prostate before your awesome blog. :)

Cheers,
Ben
brudolph@parallels.com
September 5, 2007 4:23 PM
 

markp said:

Rory, just thought I'd let you know I have switched back to Parallels from VMWare... the only thing stopping me before was the system overhead and they seem to have improved that now, so I wouldn't really worry about trying VMWare right now.

Parallels now seems to have better UI and behaviour in both Fullscreen mode (making it easy to pop between Win and Mac) and Coherence mode (what with the fancy smart select stuff)
September 23, 2007 1:30 AM
 

Rory Blyth, my hero | YuviSense: Codin Kid said:

September 25, 2007 3:59 PM
 

Stasigr said:

Hello, very nice site, keep up good job!
Admin good, very good.
October 29, 2007 7:28 AM
 

Rory - Neopoleon said:

I got a pleasant and totally unexpected invitation this week to head up to Seattle and meet the people...
November 9, 2007 1:01 AM
 

dogdieletidly said:

November 19, 2007 8:49 AM
 

THAT’S What I’m Talking About « Harlem’s Mac Blog said:

November 27, 2007 5:06 AM
New Comments to this post are disabled

About Rory

I *own* this site, you loser.